Although it's true he was the finest student that I taught,
His claim to be my best disciple doesn't square with facts
I can't ignore: he sought his liberation in his thought;
To him philosophy was like a Cretan double axe
He used to sacrifice wild states my worshippers held dear;
You'd think perhaps he was a loyal student of Apollo
Because of how he venerated everything that's clear;
He made a synthesis so singular it's hard to follow.
And yet the very challenge that he sought through integration
Of elements of darkness and of light within the soul
Provides a model for a life of human elevation
And points toward achievement of each person's highest goal.
My verdict in the end is that he was a noble liar
Whose edifying poetry was made to tell a story
Of how an individual could reach for something higher
And so emerge from weakness into splendor, power, glory.
Peter Saint-Andre > Writings > Nietzsche